I now own this sweater in black, dark brown, rust and oat all in the same size. The black and oat are similar texture and fit whereas the brown and rust are are both another. Its annoying theyre not consistent across all colours, but still lovely sweaters. Id say get the brown or rust though as they feel higher quality, fit more flattering and lay better on the body. The black and oat are a more rigid knit, so for example if you like to fold the bottom of your sweaters at the waist the black and oat both just flip back into place whereas the rust and brown both stay as is.